I’ve made no secret of the fact that I really love Windows 7. I’ve almost always been a Microsoft fan; they’ve always just given me the cleanest, most intuitive interfaces out there that show me the information that I need, without compromise. Sure I could get more functionality out of Linux if I cared to dive in deep into the command line, or I could get things more simple with OSX if I wanted to. But I don’t. I like Windows. I like a lot of information on my screen at once, and having it only a glance away.
It all really comes down to The Taskbar. This mighty bar of information has been a part of Windows since the 95 days, and it is the key visual difference between Windows and OSX to the regular user. I have equally not made a secret of the fact that I detest the OSX dock. This is the OSX dock (photo is taken from flickr; even though I have a macbook pro now, I only run Windows 7 on it and I don’t want to restart it into OSX mode just to take an original screenshot). I purposely chose a flickr photo with the dock turned to left-side, for reasons you’ll see a few paragraphs down.
What makes the dock so distasteful? It doesn’t tell me anything about a program except that it’s open. Let’s say that you’ve selected System Preferences in OSX (in that screenshot, system preferences is the 4th icon from the bottom). The icon there in the dock doesn’t change when the shortcut is clicked. It just sits there, with a bland glowing dot to its left (you can see that with the Finder window, the first icon on top), and if you start working on something else and came back to System Preferences later, you’ll need to manually click that stupid icon again and check the contents of the particular window to see what it is you had opened up. So, you have to move the mouse back to that icon, click the icon, and then wait for the screen to redraw the window. Arguably no more than 2-3 seconds – but it adds up. Mac users have to do this dozens or hundreds of times a day. That comes to minutes per day, hours per month of just time spent fighting your computer for information. The Windows taskbar, however, does not fight you. It passively and constantly displays exactly what you have open and tells you the name of the window is for that program.
Now that I have an Apple computer, when I first got it I made a conscious effort to try to stay in OSX and use it. I made a serious attempt to be an OSX user. The paragraph above describes the sole reason why I no longer bother. I even tried writing in on a few Mac-users forums to see if there was a way to add an informational taskbar to OSX. I asked very politely, but the replies were “why would you want that; that’s like Windows” and even “just get used to the OSX way of doing things.” I never went back. OSX is simply a waste of my time.
See there in that first screenshot of the Windows 7 taskbar? In a fraction of a second glance, I can see that I have Ars Technica open in a Firefox window, Pandora open in Chrome, and three system management windows open – Services, Device Manager, and Disk Management. If I know I don’t want one open, I can then choose to move my mouse, right click on it and click close. I don’t even need to look at that window again; it doesn’t redraw itself if I only right click on it. Information management, accomplished, with minimal mouse/keyboard movement.
However, Microsoft is moving backwards. What you saw above is a customized Windows 7 taskbar (as those of you who already use Windows 7 probably guessed). Microsoft no longer shows you this sort of wonderful taskbar by default. No, the Windows 7 taskbar by default looks like this.
Yes…looks kind of familiar, doesn’t it? A big, bulky taskbar that takes up more of your screen real estate vs the classic, thin variety. Large, gaudy icons that have no text on them. I took these two screenshots mere seconds apart; those are the exact same programs and windows open here as in the first picture above. But where is the information? Why, Microsoft, am I forced to look at an OSX dock when I first install Windows 7? I can see I have Chrome, Firefox, and three other weird nameless windows open (and without text, I certainly have no idea what they could be; they’re generic system management windows with no brand recognition like Chrome and Firefox).
As an I.T. admin, I work with middle-aged professors that probably started with DOS and Unix when they first began doing statistical calculations, then moved to XP, and then moved to Windows 7 when we told them their new computer was capable of it. Without fail, I always tell every single user – as they stare blankly at the oversized, pictograph taskbar on their new Windows 7 desktop – “don’t worry; if you’d like, I can change it back to the way that Windows XP arranged the taskbar.” With two exceptions out of dozens, every person has been grateful to me for showing them how to do this, and several have asked me to write it down so that they can do it to their own personal Windows 7 computers.
Right click the taskbar, click properties. Change to these settings. Fixed!
The new Windows 7 default taskbar has the exact same problem as OSX’s dock. It causes you to do more work, more mouse movement, more thinking, to merely see what’s open or running on your computer. Over the past few years, there has apparently been an outcry for “simplified” computing. Graphical User Interface (GUI) designers have responded in a lazy fashion – merely subtract information from the screen, and voila, your experience is simplified. But is it? Users of desktop and laptop computers still compute the same way. Most regular users have at least 3-4 programs open at once, and power users like myself might have 15 to 20 open. You can’t “simplify” away the fact that we need to be able to quickly navigate and filter that information, and pictures/icons simply cannot communicate details as effectively as text.
“A Picture Is Worth a Thousand Words” is true if you want to pass on the information of a painting, a movie, or a vista (pun intended). But when you’re an office worker with 4 open Word documents, 3 open emails-in-progress, a web browser, and possibly a chat program (for business or pleasure) open, seeing 4 identical Word icons, 3 identical email icons, and then two other icons for your browser and chat, is not useful simplification. Microsoft, you’ve forced that user to move the mouse over and click each icon individually to see which document is which. At least Microsoft’s implementation is better than the OSX dock, because moving your mouse over each icon in Windows will then show a popup (with text, fortunately!) of open windows/tabs/sub folders for that program, and right-clicking even gives you access to special commands and functions (called Jumplists). Here’s an example of Internet Explorer 9, with six tabs open, spread between two windows, while using the informationless-taskbar. Although better than OSX, this still requires moving your mouse over from whatever you were doing before and hovering it over the IE button to see what windows/tabs are open.













