What a first day in India! As it’s 12:17 as I put fingers onto tablet keyboard, it is now almost exactly 24 hours since I arrived into the country and it’s been pretty wild. The morning started off slow, quite literally, as the omelette breakfast that was advertised on the menu as taking 15 minutes took almost an hour. I guess I shouldn’t be too surprised; Christine already has been warning me that “Arab Time” and “Indian Time” share a lot more similarities to each other compared with “Western Time”. The food was quite tasty too – white buttered toast, a spicy omelette with onions, peppers, and cilantro in it, and a creamy coffee. The hotel staff told me (correctly) that a rickshaw to the Andheri train station would cost about 50 rupees (the driver took my sixty and didn’t offer my change but I was feeling generous and let him keep the equivalent of a dollar), but my first heart pounding moment was that I couldn’t find the danged ticket booth. I walked up and down the platforms twice, over the arching bridge connecting them, and even interrogated a bookish-looking young guy (I operated on the assumption that they would speak English several times today, and haven’t been wrong yet) as to whether we just provided the 5 rupee fare on the train. Nope – there was a ticket booth, I just had to find it, which I finally did, buried around a corner behind some billboards for popcorn and snacks. Half of the time during this search, I had been dogged by a sad-looking girl, who had to be between 5-7 who was holding a baby in her arms. She would tug on my arm as I was walking, and if I stopped to puzzle over the ticket kiosk’s hidden location, she immediately fell to my feet and started touching them, then touching her forehead. For the first few minutes I gently and sadly told her in English “no money, no change, I’m sorry” (and I really didn’t; all I had was 1000 rupee bills left in my pocket from the ATM).
With ticket in hand and a few small change bills in my pocket, I walked triumphantly back to the platform, and happened to see the same girl standing with a woman that I assumed was her equally poor mother. I proudly handed a 20 rupee bill (the equivalent of 4 train tickets halfway across the city or a couple good meals) to the woman, and walked onto the train. Suddenly a swarm of children surrounded me, chorusing “money mister money mister money mister” over and over again in some sort of eerie high-pitched drone. I thought I’d be safe on the train, but they followed me onto the train and proceeded to continue to touching my feet. The gruff looking Indian men around me, young and old, looked rather embarrassed and they tried to shoo the children off me. “Mister,” they said, gesturing to the children, then to me, and then pantomimed a “tsk tsk” motion. “They go then.” I saw the little girl with the baby, and gave her a 10 rupee bill, and the girl next to her a 5 rupee coin, then showed them my empty change pocket. The littler one pouted at the 5 rupee coin, and pointed at the 10 bill in her hand. “Wasn’t that your mother back there?” I asked in exasperation. “No mother mister, no mother” was the response. But the train was leaving, and the kids melted away, the men shaking their heads in irritation in the direction of the beggars and flicking their newspapers open. And beside a few stares from new people getting onto the train, I was mostly ignored for the slow, clanking ride to Mahim station.
The doors were never shut, people were literally hanging out of the door like the enjoyed the natural “air conditioning” it provided (headless to the huge signs in English and Sanskrit warning of the fact that this was an electric train that used 25,000 volts to run) and a massive rush of humanity shoved silently to get on and off the train at every stop. A group of young students in uniforms came on the train about 15 minutes into the ride, a couple of them produced some little cymbals and bells, and they all begin singing a rhythmic upbeat song in either Hindi or Marati (the local state language – I can’t tell the difference of course). They sounded pretty good too. I was watching carefully to see how early people got up from their seats (if they were the 30% like me who had gotten on at the end of the line and gotten seats; most people were standing and crushing into the aisles and doors) and was able to leap out at Mahim, just as the train started moving.
At Mahim, I met up with my new tour guides and tour group – Nilesh, our young guide, a couple of Australian women named Steph and Anita, and a Hollander named Bart. The rain had been drizzling nonstop all morning, and we splashed over the uneven cracked pavement a bit north of Mahim towards the Dhavari Slum. Nilesh worked for a group called Reality Tours, the only Dhavari touring group that was a registered NGO and gives back 80% of all tour income to the slums to run schools for children, job-education centers for adults, and nutrition/sexual health schools for expecting mothers. Nilesh was a small fellow with shaggy black hair, a trim little goatee, and twinkling eyes. He seemed to enjoy his work quite a bit as he led us first through the commercial section where they recycled the garbage that Mumbaites leave in heaping piles all over the city, stitched together garments for factories, and make bread for both personal sale and for restaurants. The recycling part was particularly interesting – Nilesh told us that the slum was one by technical name only – the 1km clump of land was government owned, but for a hundred years squatters had been throwing up first metal, then concrete shanties and houses and starting small businesses in them. But the Indians are resourceful people – although many of their devices look ramshackle by Western standards, they are masters of working with what they’ve got. We got to see the rooms were bales of crushed lawn chairs, CRT monitor bases (I knew the plastic from the screens we actually pay to get rid of at the University were getting reused somehow!) were stored, and the rooms were large metal machines ground them into pellet form and where those pellets were stored so that Samsung and LG could buy them from the slum laborers and reuse them into making smartphone bodies. Just think – the next time you hoist your plastic-bodied phone, remember that it was likely touched by an industrious team of Indian workers in Mumbai. Their pay is measly though – 8 rupees per kilogram of plastic, and 5 for the same weight of paper. I compared that to Jordan in my head – when I was there, a laborer could make 20-30 gersh (50 cents or so) for a kilo of paper. That’s over triple the price. We even saw the rooms where the grinding machines were being welded, put together, and painted, and smaller rooms where smelters were making their gears. Now that’s local business.
Then we crossed the street into the residential area of the slum, which is defined as “not having any toxic manufacturing processes happening in it” My poor sandals, already in beat up shape from Thailand and Malaysia, probably won’t survive this trip between the constantly pouring rain and the trudging through industrial waste water. Children ran around us now, cheering hello over and over again. Nilesh patted one on the head and told us “these kids won’t beg from you, they see that I’m with you, they see the tour guide logo on my shirt, and they know that your visit is improving their life here.” And he was right – not a single person begged money from us in all of Dhavari. Nilesh had told us that these were a proud hardworking people who didn’t want to feel exploited, and in fact they wanted to share their hardworking lives with western tourists. Photography was understandably forbidden in the entire slum while travelling with the Reality Tours group – ever since the area was used as the background for the massively successful Slumdog Millionaire movie, the residents were irritated with tourists tramping through and photographing their poverty, and Reality certainly wasn’t going to contribute to that.
Continue reading this post…


